討論:宣統帝

由Joker Twins在話題Requested Move:「清宣統帝」→「溥儀」上作出的最新留言:一 年前

此條目之主名

大典成例,君王以廟號立條,然溥儀逢兩千年未有之變,終老共黨之地,舊習盡廢,雖有偏安苗裔上尊號,亦未為世所廣知,則其傅當用何稱之?以名諱乎?以廟號乎?以年號乎?請諸君不吝賜教。夏侯 韜 (talk) 二〇一三年一月一六日 (三) 一三時二二分 (UTC)回覆

模板:意见 末帝庙号一事以在下所知乃为其宗族所拟,现所陵亦是商贾所资。在下认为可用宗族所拟,且亦有书籍文章用之。--Jyu..(~福气世界~) (talk) 二〇一三年一月一六日 (三) 一五時二三分 (UTC)回覆

Requested Move:「清宣統帝」→「溥儀」

溥儀 used 宣統 as his era name for Qing dynasty, and used 大同 and 康德 as his era name for Manchukuo. Thus, this article should name by his personal name 溥儀, instead of his era name.--Joker Twins留言二〇二三年三月二八日 (二) 〇五時三八分 (UTC)回覆

(+) 可也。 -- Illud Sine Nomine留言二〇二三年三月二九日 (三) 一三時一四分 (UTC)回覆

所謂宣統者,清之溥儀之年號也。所謂大同、康德者,滿洲國之溥儀之年號也。有清一朝,未有大同、康德年號,正如滿洲國十數年未有宣統年號也。故以清宣統帝稱溥儀,未有不妥之處。恕不讚此案。——魔琴 [ ] 二〇二三年四月四日 (二) 一二時五五分 (UTC)回覆
溥儀 is his personal name, which can refer to himself for his whole life. 清宣統帝 can only refer to his life in Qing dyansty, however it was just 6 years, nearly only a tenth of his whole life. In addition, he was also the head of state of Manchukuo during 大同 and 康德 era. Thus, 溥儀 is the best title of this article.--Joker Twins留言二〇二三年四月四日 (二) 一四時二四分 (UTC)回覆
返「宣統帝」。